Electronic Stability Program

During critical maneuvers, such as an obstacle avoidance, a vehicle can easily become uncontrollable due to excessive skidding. While performing a steering maneuver, especially at high speeds, significant lateral forces are acting on tires. These forces are responsible for the yaw moment acting on the vehicle which finally set its orientation. If these forces though reach their limit due to traction, the vehicle is unable to perform the desired maneuver and becomes unstable. For this reason, Electronic Stability Program (ESP) is introduced.

ESP is a driver assist system that improves vehicle’s stability through intervention in the braking system. By individual wheel braking ESP can control the yaw moment of the vehicle, thus its steering behavior.

In modern vehicles, where a hydraulic modulator is used as part of the ABS, ESP can take advantage of system’s pump and solenoid valves to modulate pressure at individual wheels without the need of brake application from the driver. ESP’s main logic is to calculate the desired yaw rate and side slip angle of the vehicle, depending on lateral dynamics of steady state single-track vehicle model, and introduce the desired braking force to counter understeer (#1 in the figure below) or oversteer (#2 in the figure below ).
Figure 1. ESP Braking Action During Understeer or Oversteer


A brake intervention ESP is available in the Assembly Wizard plug-in for a Disk-Brake system. As shown in the figure of a typical ESP set up below, basic parts of the braking system are modeled in MotionView while ESP ECU, ABS ECU, and Hydraulic Modulator are modeled in Twin Activate and are exported as FMU.
Figure 2. ESP Intervention in the Brake System


ESP Module in Twin Activate

The complete ESP block is shown below:
Figure 3. ESP Block in Twin Activate


Some of the inputs represent signals from sensors (wheels velocities, vehicle long and lateral velocity, steering angle, yaw rate) while the rest are connecting the hydraulics parts from MotionView to the ones in Twin Activate (Master cylinder pressure). Vehicle velocities are usually estimated rather than measured. In the current implementation these values were used as outputs from MBS vehicle model in order to focus on the control system’s behavior.

ESP Electronic Control Unit

The ESP electronic control unit is responsible for calculating the desired yaw rate and desired side-slip angle using certain inputs and vehicle parameters. Then depending on the error between reference and actual values, a desired braking force signal is created for the hydraulic modulator.
Figure 4. ESP Electronic Control Unit in Twin Activate


Yaw rate and side-slip angle reference value
The reference yaw rate and side-slip angle values can be obtained by linearizing the steady-state equations of motion of single-track vehicle model.

For the yaw rate reference value:

Where is vehicle’s longitudinal velocity, front wheels steering angle, vehicle’s wheelbase and the desired understeering coefficient. The actual understeer coefficient of the vehicle can be calculated by the following formula:

Where are front and rear axle cornering stiffness, are distance of front and rear axle from the vehicle’s center of gravity and is the vehicle’s mass.

For the calculation of the yaw rate reference it is also important to take into consideration the upper bound of friction limit between tire and road.

For this reason

Where

Where is the friction coefficient between tire and road and is gravity’s acceleration.

So, the final yaw rate reference in order to avoid discontinuity can be calculated as shown below:

Where

For the side-slip reference:

In Twin Activate equations (1) and (2) can be implemented as shown below:
Figure 5. Yaw Rate and Side-Slip Angle Reference in Twin Activate


For the calculation of reference values, except from and signals that come from MotionView, some parameters should also be set in model initialization in Twin Activate as shown below:
Figure 6. ESP Parameters in Twin Activate


Control Law
As mentioned before, ESP uses the error of the yaw rate and the side-slip angle to generate the desired yaw moment for the vehicle. Thus, the control law can be represented as a Proportional controller as shown below:


Where and are the proportional gains of the controller.
Figure 7. ESP Control Law in Twin Activate


As stated earlier, ESP’s actuator is the vehicle brake system. The desired yaw moment of the vehicle is created by individual wheel braking.

In case of understeering, the front axle is losing grip, therefore the rear wheel is braked while in case of oversteering, the rear axle is losing grip and the front wheel is braked. Thus, by having the turn’s orientation (left or right) and the understeer condition of the vehicle (understeer or oversteer) the optimal tire is selected for braking in order to produce the desired yaw moment. The tire selection algorithm as created in Twin Activate is shown below:
Figure 8. Tire Selection from ESP in Twin Activate


The desired yaw moment for the vehicle should be expressed in desired caliper pressure which will be then produced by the hydraulic modulator. The yaw moment is first expressed in longitudinal force on tire, by using the proper track width (front or rear). Then braking torque using tire’s radius and finally the braking pressure using brake systems parameters. Implementation in Twin Activate is shown below:
Figure 9. Yaw Moment to Brake Pressure in Twin Activate


ABS

To prevent wheel lock during ESP’s braking, ABS, as a lower-level controller, monitors longitudinal slip. Just like in a braking condition, brake pressure is modulated by the ABS ECU through the hydraulic modulator so that the pressure can either increase, hold, or decrease. Additional information on ABS design logic and function can be found in the Anti-lock Braking System topic.

Create a Full Vehicle Model with ESP

The MBD-Vehicle Dynamics Tools must be loaded as a Preference file.
  1. From the File menu, select Load > Preference File > MBD-Vehicle Dynamics Tools.
    Figure 10.


  2. From the Model menu, select Assembly Wizard.
    Figure 11.


  3. Under Select ABS/ESP and TC an Electronic Stability Program (ESP) option will be available for selection.
    Figure 12.


  4. Completing the Assembly Wizard's selections will lead to a full vehicle model with Altair Driver and a Electronic Stability Program.
    Figure 13.


    Figure 14.